13 Feb UK Study Finds E-Cigarettes Helps People Quit Smoking…But U.S. Researchers Are Wary Of Results
A new study published in the New England Journal of Medicine found that in a group of UK adult smokers, e-cigarettes paired with one-on-one behavior therapy were almost twice as effective than other cigarette cessation products in helping to quit traditional cigarette smoking. The study had two randomized groups: the e-cigarette group and the traditional nicotine replacement group (participants had option to choose from a range of cessation products such as patches and gum). Each group also paired their cessation devices with behavioral therapy. At one year follow up, 18% of the e-cigarette group had abstained from smoking traditional cigarettes, compared to about 10% in the traditional nicotine replacement group.
Although these results seem to be promising, U.S. researchers are not enthusiastic. The field of research is slim with e-cigarette findings, mainly due to the fact that e-cigarette use has only recently started growing in popularity. Therefore, no conclusive study has been conducted to demonstrate the potential short and long-term effects of e-cigarette smoking. So while e-cigarettes may have helped this group of cigarette smokers quit, a result that may not generalize to the U.S., researchers are unsure of the physical detriments of vaping that may overshadow the benefits of cigarette smoking cessation. “E-cigarettes have volatile organic compounds, cancer causing chemicals, and flavorings that have been linked to lung disease,” said smoking cessation researcher Belinda Borrelli. “Let’s not say e-cigarettes are a magic pill to help people quit smoking without having all of the information.”
It is also worth noting that among participants with 1 year of abstinence from cigarette smoking, a whopping 80% of the e-cigarette group were still using e-cigarettes, compared to only 9% of participants in the traditional nicotine replacement group who were still using the replacements. Therefore, while those participants may have ceased smoking cigarettes, they remain nicotine-dependent by continuing to use e-cigarettes.
For more information from the CNN article, click here.